Sydney Morning Herald – Paul Bibby – March 8, 2010
ELEMENTS of Islamic law – the sharia – should be legally recognised in Australia so that Muslims can live according their faith, a prominent Muslim leader says.

Addressing an open day at Lakemba Mosque on Saturday, the president of the Australian Islamic Mission, Zachariah Matthews, said parts of sharia could be recognised as a secondary legal system so that Muslims were not forced to act contrary to their beliefs. ”Sharia law could function as a parallel system in the same way that some traditional Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander law was recognised in the Northern Territory,” Dr Matthews told the Herald after the session.

”I don’t think we are so unsophisticated that we cannot consider a multilayered legal system as long as it doesn’t conflict with the existing civil system.”

The comments shocked some attending the open day. They felt Dr Matthews was advocating the introduction of the penal system under which women have been stoned to death for adultery, and corporal punishment is meted out for some offences.”It came as quite a shock to some non-Muslims in the crowd when sharia law and the idea of a parallel legal system was mentioned,” one audience member, Jasmine Donnelly, said.

”One group of people just left straight after that.”

But Dr Matthews said he was referring only to certain elements of family law and inheritance law and was not advocating the sharia penal system.

”I wasn’t talking about sharia law in its entirety – we are not calling for the introduction of the penal system which calls for cutting off hands,” he said.

Dr Matthews said a clash occurred in some custody matters. ”Under sharia law, if a couple divorce and the mother remarries, her former husband has the right to decide whether the children will live with the new husband or not,” Dr Matthews said.

”There is still a preference for the child to go with the mother, but the father has the ultimate decision.

”This does not exist in Australian law but I do not believe it clashes fundamentally with Australian values or the Australian legal system.”

2 Responses to “Muslim leader wants elements of sharia in Australia”

  1. 1 Jim P

    This no doubt would be the thin edge of the wedge. It is always a one way street with muslims trying to change non-muslim countries’ laws to suit their culture. I think Mr Costello provided the definative statement i.e.” if a muslim wants to live under sharia law then he should live in a muslim country”.

  2. 2 joan cross

    Sharia law, particularly in relation to family and divorce matters, is blatantly biased against women and supportive of men’s authority over women. Under sharia, it is much harder for a women to divorce her husband than a man to divorce his wife. Uder sharia, the women is in effect under the total control of her husband, cannot leave the home without his permission, and cannot have the overriding decision about who the children live with – this decision is, as the imam clearly stated, one for the father. Hasn’t this imam noticed that he is living in a secular modern society where the laws give male and female equal rights? Hasn’t he noticed that we as a society will no longer tolerate such blatant discrimination and oppression of women? If he wants to live under sharia law (and I can see why many Moslem men would want to, given that it allows dominance of men over women) then go and live in a theocracy, not in a modern, progressive nationa like Australia.

Leave a Reply

Youtube Highlights

Australia Day 2019
Click Here for 3AW Interviews


3K2 theme by Hakan Aydin